« VIDEO: They Might Be Giants - 'With the Dark' | Main | Largehearted Boy's Interesting CD Releases This Week »
Posted in music on June 11, 2007
a letter from one disappointed M.I.A. fan

"Jrak" writes in...
M.I.A.'s first album bombed in sales given all the hype, and I think this one will do even worse, and HERE'S WHY. I was fairly psyched to watch the Boyz video on BV today, but about 1/4 through I was insanely bored with it and had to stop watching. M.I.A.'s first album was so great because it was so weird for the time, but now mainstream R&B has gotten so weird in its production itself (your Timbalands, etc) that M.I.A. doesn't have that angle anymore of sounding unique and like nothing else. She's just another rapper/singer, and SURPRISE, her voice isn't good. Without being distracted by all the fancy and crazy blips and bloops, you realize she's just not much else. More proof of mainsteam R&B being the new hipster music, and teenage girls being way ahead of anything Ed Banger is gonna throw at you. Wouldn't you rather listen to pretty much anything by Rihanna than the new MIA? Just my two cents.
Posted on June 11, 2007 11:28 AM
Leave a comment
Powered by Ajax Comments
« VIDEO: They Might Be Giants - 'With the Dark' | Main | Largehearted Boy's Interesting CD Releases This Week »
Comments (28)
Yea, and what's up with t-pain getting added to the Siren lineup?
Posted by Jeff | June 11, 2007 11:44 AM
first 1/4 is mostly instrumental...
Posted by Anonymous | June 11, 2007 11:51 AM
the MIA first album was fun for about 2 weeks...once the buzz faded, it was pretty worthless.
no one will care about the new album. she's not hip anymore so its doubtful people will flock to her.
Posted by Anonymous | June 11, 2007 11:53 AM
boyz and bird flu are terrible non singles that were pushed as singles. THere is no Galang on this album. I was a fan, but count me bored seneseless
Posted by Anonymous | June 11, 2007 11:58 AM
he had me until "rihanna". i agree that modern r+b is the weird hotness, although that's not exactly new (see Missy, Ciara, Neptunes, etc.) but you can't say that MIA sucks because she can't sing and then praise that rihanna. streisand she ain't.
Posted by Anonymous | June 11, 2007 12:07 PM
did this leak yet?
Posted by Anonymous | June 11, 2007 12:11 PM
First off. I personally like the tracks. One I know they work on the dance floor becuase I have spin them. These are dance tracks with experiments in sampling different sounds. It is not meant for uppity people who don't like to dance. But these are escape songs that's all. And to make them more than what they are, is silly.
Any inner city club in the world has music like this and is mean for escapism. Whether Dancehall, Gheto House, DC GO GO, Baile Funk, or Grime.
People hate what they do not understand.
That is my two cents.
Posted by Tarik | June 11, 2007 12:11 PM
did this leak yet?
Posted by Anonymous | June 11, 2007 12:12 PM
hm, i think MIA opened the doors with her first album. brought something that has been around for a while to the mainstream (think Madonna).
but opening the doors lead to some far more interesting artists... I'd much rather listen to Bonde do Role or Santogold or Switch then MIA these days... even Timbaland on his own is better then these new MIA joints.
She needs to find an "unknown" producer and create something our ears aren't used to --- that was the success of her first album. I hate to say it, but she does have much talent on her own to float a project by herself (think Madonna).
Posted by Travis | June 11, 2007 12:30 PM
hm, i think MIA opened the doors with her first album. brought something that has been around for a while to the mainstream (think Madonna).
but opening the doors lead to some far more interesting artists... I'd much rather listen to Bonde do Role or Santogold or Switch then MIA these days... even Timbaland on his own is better then these new MIA joints.
She needs to find an "unknown" producer and create something our ears aren't used to --- that was the success of her first album. I hate to say it, but she does have much talent on her own to float a project by herself (think Madonna).
Posted by Travis | June 11, 2007 12:30 PM
oh and Tarik: i think the problem is people understand these sounds all too well these days... and know that others do it better.
i mean just look at deize tigrona's injecao . had that song made any impact in the states or the uk mia would've never had a career.
people flock to what is new to them.
Posted by Travis | June 11, 2007 12:36 PM
I'm sickened from cyber-dysentery after reading so much verbal diarrhea. All commenters here belong in the "i take things way too seriously" or, "the ficklest of the fickle" categories. Both incredibly lame.
Posted by Anonymous | June 11, 2007 12:38 PM
JRak's post seems to assume that Timbaland wasn't making mainstream R&B "weird" prior to M.I.A., which is just not true. Take a look at what he did for Aaliyah ("Are You That Somebody" with the inexplicable baby giggle) for one. The reason for M.I.A.'s rise has more to do with how she was introduced. The Diplo-helmed mixtape/CD she did rapping over popular tunes combined with the intense dancehall (another genre experiencing mainstream success at the time) of "Galang" made her a standout. She was riding the hype of the indie music press, and God bless her for it.
Now, if anything, she's suffering from the good ol' fashioned sophomore slump, unable to find a single that will remind people why she packed Summerstage just two years ago.
Posted by Anonymous | June 11, 2007 12:43 PM
yeah, so all i gots to say about MIA is that her sharks at her record label shut down my blog twice by going to my host and having them flip the switch off without any notice... i mean, sure legally they can do that but its not cool. especially coming from MIA! didn't she tell everyone to pirate her shit? out of all music i've ever posted on the internet MIA is the ONLY artist who has ever given me shit... and shit on me... by taking 3 days to reveal contact info so i could get my site back up and running.
oh yeah, and they made me take down all my remixes of her shit too!? the ones that were unofficial releases! MIA you're a whore to the labels, you've sold out and hurt your fans...
but secretly i still like you. maybe.
Posted by Chaz | June 11, 2007 12:45 PM
I just check Siren's website and MySpace and saw nothing about T-Pain being added to the lineup
Posted by b.LOUD | June 11, 2007 1:42 PM
um, yea, exactly, tim and missy and neptunes have been making wierd shit forever. I see nothing in that linked post that is anyway "proof" that mainstream R&B is the new hipster music. I do like that rihanna "umbrella" single but rihanna and amerie better than Ed Banger??? please.
Posted by Ben B | June 11, 2007 1:47 PM
her shit's getting weak, but i'd still hit it.
Posted by Anonymous | June 11, 2007 1:55 PM
I agree, for the most part. I definitely wouldn't rather listen to Rhianna though. "ella, ella, ella" that shit annoys the fuck out of me.
Posted by eyelasssh | June 11, 2007 3:04 PM
I loved MIA's first album but recognize that it had mostly to do with Diplo. I think she was really just a vehicle for some interesting sounds and fun beats. I saw her at SOB's two years ago and she was essentially booed off the stage because she is such a bad singer. She's simply an indie-beats Britney Spears, with good producers behind her; nothing more.
Posted by Anthropoid | June 11, 2007 3:30 PM
I think it'd be best for you to listen to the whole song!
It's rather ecstatic and fun for both genders,
also, it begins and ends really well,
rihanna's current single is disembodied and very much a good song gone bad, totally cop out ending
Posted by Anonymous | June 11, 2007 5:32 PM
hey everyone thanks for killing my enthusiasm for this song. Jrak, i'm sure you're whipping up the nextest shit imaginable.
Posted by Anonymous | June 11, 2007 11:08 PM
i never liked M.I.A. to begin with.
Posted by Anonymous | June 12, 2007 4:22 PM
MIA is confirmed for siren festival now
Posted by jobcain | June 13, 2007 12:37 PM
uhh... didn't Neneh Cherry do this a decade ago already? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3EQCOshGwPI
Posted by fredie | June 13, 2007 5:07 PM
I liked her first album, still do, and am looking forward to the next one. Here's where the gap between popular music whores and die-hard fans gets wider.
Posted by Anonymous | July 4, 2007 12:01 AM
I love it very much. Jamaican culture is all around us in parts of London and M.I.A's doing a nice take on the authentic ting...Typical how the trendy privileged lot get bored. I think she is an important musician and role model encouraging our youths in becoming politically conscious...I want ghetto kids to love her, not just trendy kids with no real empathy..
Posted by nas | July 10, 2007 3:29 PM
is it so last season to be from a war-torn nation...?
oh please, you new york hipster /slash emo slash wanna-be anything you think makes you unique and totally different is soo lame. Suddenly Hip-Hop is an area any you fools know anything about. M.I.A. is divine she's a hot dancer, she is smart, beautiful, talented and very original ---- and she even has substance, this I realize may be difficult to see from behind your crappy eighties fringe bangs and the cloud of cigarette smoke. Go back to Catpower we don't want you anyway. White wonder bread ain't got shit on multi grain.
Posted by Trini Mommi | October 18, 2007 3:38 PM
lol
Posted by Anonymous | August 30, 2008 12:07 PM