On Nick Cave's The Red Hand Files website, where you can submit him questions, someone (named G) asked him "What would be a list of 10 of your most favourite pieces of music, by artists other than yourself? And number 11 must be a Gun Club song," and another person (named William) asked the similar question "Can you put together a list of your top five albums and ask Warren Ellis to do the same?"

Nick didn't necessarily reply with his "most favourite" pieces of music, but he took the question in a similar, possibly more exciting direction. He referenced his poem "The Sick Bag Song," in which he wrote about Leonard Cohen and how in life there will be "songs – not many – ten or maybe twenty in a lifespan, that stand apart from the rest of the music [one discovers]" that Nick referred to as "hiding songs." He then went on to explain how people have occasionally asked him what his "hiding songs" were, songs that feel like "they were designed with you especially in mind, and that no one could ever begin to understand them in the way you do?," and then he provided a list of his ten "hiding songs," including Leonard Cohen's "Avalanche" (which Nick covered on his debut solo album), as well as songs by Karen Dalton, Neil Young, John Lee Hooker, Van Morrison, Bob Dylan, Nina Simone, Big Star, Brian Eno, and Bill Callahan. And, per G's re quest, Nick Cave picked "Mother of Earth" by The Gun Club.

Warren Ellis also put together a list of his top five albums, as the second fan, William, had requested. Check out both lists, listen to a playlist of Nick Cave's "hiding songs," and read Nick's full response below.


Dear G and William,

In my extended poem, “The Sick Bag Song”, I wrote about Leonard Cohen and the effect that he had on me as a young boy when I first heard him sing.

“Leonard Cohen will sing, and the boy will suddenly breathe as if for the first time, and fall inside the laughing man’s voice and hide.

The boy will grow older, and over time there will be other songs – not many – ten or maybe twenty in a lifespan, that stand apart from the rest of the music he will discover. He will realise that not only are these songs sacred, they are ‘hiding songs’ that deal exclusively in darkness, obfuscation, concealment and secrecy. He will realise that for him the purpose of these songs was to shut off the sun, to draw a long shadow down and protect him from the corrosive glare of the world.”


Occasionally people have asked me what those ‘hiding songs’ were. I have never revealed them in their entirety. Perhaps, I felt a strange ownership over them and that to release them to the world may constitute a form of betrayal. Do you ever feel like that about songs – that they were designed with you especially in mind, and that no one could ever begin to understand them in the way you do? My ‘hiding songs’ serve as a form of refuge for me and have done so for years. They are songs that I can pull over myself, like a child might pull the bed covers over their head, when the blaze of the world becomes too intense. I can literally hide inside them. They are the essential pillars that hold up the structure of my artistic world. There are hundreds of other favourite songs, of course, and one day maybe I can do a list of some of those, but not today. Today, I give you the ‘hiding songs’.

G and William (and anyone else, for that matter), I’d be interested to know if you have any ‘hiding songs’, and if so what they are. You know where to find me!

Avalanche, Leonard Cohen
Katie Cruel, Karen Dalton
On the Beach, Neil Young
Tupelo, John Lee Hooker
T.B. Sheets, Van Morrison
It’s All Over Now, Baby Blue, Bob Dylan
Plain Gold Ring, Nina Simone
Holocaust, Big Star
Becalmed, Brian Eno
One Fine Morning, Bill Callahan


William, I called Warren in Paris. He was happy to make you a list of his top five albums.

Warren Ellis' Top Five Albums Of All Time
World Galaxy, Alice Coltrane With Strings
The Rite of Spring, Igor Stravinsky
Another Green World, Brian Eno
I’m New Here, Gil Scott-Heron
The Velvet Underground & Nico


Oh, and G – ‘Mother of Earth’ by The Gun Club.


More From Brooklyn Vegan